Democrats have made it clear all through 2020 that they don’t like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, however 
Brzezinski, referring to a South Florida Solar Sentinel report revealed final Friday, made surprising allegations relating to Gov. DeSantis’ dealing with of the coronavirus pandemic in Florida, together with that he “deliberately engaged in a sample of spin and concealment that misled the general public.” Expressing her disgust, the MSNBC host added: “My God, I imply, what does it take, uh, to be accused of breaking the legislation at this level? As governor, is not your job to tell the general public and maintain them protected?”
Rep. Stephanie Murphy (D-Fla.) primarily agreed with Brzezinski, however didn’t give her any recommendation for placing DeSantis behind bars. This wasn’t an issue, nevertheless, as a result of Palm Seashore County State Legal professional and Morning Joe common Dave Aronberg was simply ready to be pulled into the dialog. Brzezinski began throwing out concepts, in search of avenues to prosecute the governor:
Dave, if the governor of a state purposefully withholds info that might—that might save lives, and purposely doesn’t observe CDC tips that might save lives, is that at any level some kind of willful act that might add as much as against the law or what? The place are we?
Aronberg, being considerably life like, informed her: “It’s important to meet a really excessive burden, Mika. It is not sufficient simply to disregard CDC tips. I imply, the Trump administration is doing that on a regular basis, and it is their very own tips. You’d have to point out some actual excessive degree of fraud right here.” Though he was clearly pissed off with DeSantis as effectively.
After giving Rep. Murphy a short likelihood to bash Republicans in Congress, Brzezinski dismissed her, and as soon as once more demonstrated to Aronberg that she didn’t perceive due course of:
Alright, uh, Congresswoman Stephanie Murphy, thanks. Dave Aronberg, simply actually rapidly, having individuals delete info in authorities web sites, I—I’m—I’m nonetheless confused as to how that is not fraudulent. Denying individuals info, altering it, deleting it.
Aronberg, conscious that they would want greater than final Friday’s problem of the Solar Sentinel for a authorized case, as soon as once more tried to assist the MSNBC host conceptualize the “burden of proof” facet in prison proceedings, however it was not clear on the finish of the phase whether or not she understood.
This mock trial was delivered to you by Mazda. Inform them what you assume by clicking on the hyperlink.
Discover the transcript beneath:
MSNBC’s Morning Joe
12/07/20
8:53:06 AMMIKA BRZEZINSKI: A priority from Dr. Deborah Birx comes because the Solar Sentinel on Friday revealed a report on Governor Ron DeSantis’ dealing with of the coronavirus pandemic, and discovered that he deliberately engaged in a sample of spin and concealment that misled the public. Based mostly on interviews with extra than 50 state workers, docs and political leaders, as effectively as 4,000 pages of paperwork, the Sentinel stories the DeSantis administration refused to disclose particulars about infections in faculties, prisons, hospitals and nursing properties till compelled to by authorized motion. Becoming a member of us now, Congresswoman Stephanie Murphy of Florida who was just lately appointed Chief Deputy Whip of the Home Democratic Social gathering. My God, I imply, what does it take, uh, to be accused of breaking the legislation at this level? As governor, is not your job to inform the general public and maintain them protected?
REP. STEPHANIE MURPHY [D-FLA.]: Properly, it is nice to be with you this morning. I am sorry that that is what we’re having to speak about. However Governor DeSantis’ response to this pandemic has been marked with not solely incompetence, however this harmful misinformation, withholding important knowledge from the general public. He has failed Floridians. And the result’s that they’re dropping their lives and their livelihoods. I labored on the Division of Protection on pandemics, um, again within the early 2000s, and I do know that the path out of a pandemic is via science and medication. And for him to suppress the information that’s so wanted to make good selections, whether or not that’s about sending your youngsters to varsities, or what you are able to do, how protected it’s so that you can interact, um, in commerce and different issues, all of that info relies on the knowledge that this governor is withholding from Floridians. Um, it’s—it’s negligent. And it’s costing individuals their lives.
BRZEZINSKI: The—ah—the query I’ve is, is it—is it willful, uh, and purposeful? Let’s carry within the State Legal professional for Palm Seashore County, Dave Aronberg. Dave, if the governor of a state purposefully withholds info that might—that might save lives, and purposely doesn’t observe CDC tips that might save lives, is that at any level some kind of willful act that might add up to against the law or what? The place are we?
DAVE ARONBERG [STATE ATTY, PALM BEACH CO., FLA.]: It’s important to meet a really excessive burden, Mika. It is not sufficient simply to disregard CDC tips. I imply, the Trump administration is doing that on a regular basis, and it is their very own tips. You’d have to point out some actual excessive degree of fraud right here. Um, that is nothing new to the State of Florida, as a result of Rebecca Jones, the whistleblower, who used to run our state’s COVID web site, she stated that she was informed to delete knowledge that might point out that the state knew about COVID in advance of after they reported it. Plus, she stated that she was informed to alter knowledge that confirmed that the unfold in rural communities was larger than reported. After which there was a case of the medical experts, the place the medical experts had a better loss of life toll, however the State of Florida did not like what they have been reporting so ordered the medical experts to cease reporting their figures. I suppose that is the scientific precept that should you shut your eyes you may make all of it go away. However probably the most disturbing factor, Mika, about the story within the Solar Sentinel was the report in regards to the 2006 legislation that the state handed to create an institute of rising pathogens on the College of Florida. They created a bunch of specialists who come collectively to cope with conditions like this, however the governor has ignored their recommendation, and as an alternative is counting on Dr. Scott Atlas, the identical physician who has no expertise in infectious ailments, and has led our nation’s COVID response into the ditch. So should you’re questioning why a state like Florida, with greater than 1 million COVID instances, nonetheless is just one of 13 states with no masks mandate, now you realize why.
BRZEZINSKI: God. Uh, and lawmakers at this time could not, uh, make at this time’s self-imposed deadline, uh, lawmakers in Washington, for releasing the textual content of the COVID-19 aid bundle. And they’ll positively not embrace one other $1200 cost to People. President-Elect Joe Biden was amongst these hoping negotiations would produce a second wave of the very talked-about stipend, however the Related Press stories, the invoice will solely present an additional $300 monthly in federal unemployment as direct help. Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders stated he’ll oppose any invoice that does not embrace the $1200 cost, however progressive Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez she says she stays open to it. Uhh, Congresswoman Murphy, what’s it going to take to assist individuals who are struggling, and, um, a few of them, you realize, have—don’t have any monetary legs to face on now.
MURPHY: , for months I’ve been pushing for a bipartisan COVID aid invoice, and I feel the Senate proposal has framework. It brings either side again to the negotiating desk and so they’re having actual conversations. However that—that is—that could be a step ahead, though not one which I am certain the American individuals really feel quite a bit of hope in as a result of they do not but see the cash of their pockets or the assist, um, into legislation. However—you will have—we now have to know, um, that Republicans have not been critical about negotiating. Their facet hasn’t even put a b—invoice collectively that’s remotely life like, or that may—has an opportunity to be, uh—cross the Senate. Look, I feel Democrats must make laborious compromises right here. Now we have chilly laborious months forward of us, and there isn’t any extra time to waste, significantly in Florida, the place our state unemployment is disastrously low. Look, we on the federal degree have the flexibility to assist the American individuals at this time, and we want to consider it as a down cost. We will and will do extra to assist staff and American companies get via this winter, after which we are able to battle for extra sooner or later.
BRZEZINSKI: Alright, uh, Congresswoman Stephanie Murphy, thanks. Dave Aronberg, simply actually rapidly, having individuals delete info in authorities web sites, I—I’m—I’m nonetheless confused as to how that is not fraudulent. Denying individuals info, altering it, deleting it.
ARONBERG: Mika, uh she has the—Rebecca Jones, who’s the database supervisor, has, uh, come out publicly, and there’s apparently some whistleblower grievance and civil, uh, litigation on the market, however so far as prison issues, that you must present actually a excessive burden as a result of the governor enjoys a degree of sovereign immunity. However not like the president, the governor is topic to an indictment whereas he’s in workplace. There is no DOJ coverage that protects state governors from an indictment from a sitting district lawyer. All of it is determined by the information. And should you’re questioning about whether or not the voters can recall the governor in Florida, we shouldn’t have that energy. So, actually, the primary solution to change the—who—who leads the state from the highest, is on the poll field in 2022, however will probably be effectively after COVID has handed us, so the governor’s relying on that, so he can wait this disaster out.